ManageEngine AD管理 vs Netwrix审计

ManageEngine ADSolutions产品套件与Netwrix产品的比较。

特性	描述	ManageEngine ADManager Plus	NetWrix
Active Directory帐户管理
用户生命周期管理	在Active Directory中创建、管理和删除用户帐户、计算机、组和联系人
用户帐户解除配置	删除用户帐户时，他们变成不活动或禁用或过期
批量恢复已删除的用户	还原Active Directory中已删除的用户
组生命周期管理	在Active Directory中创建和管理安全性组和分发组
计算机生命周期管理	创建和管理活动目录中的计算机
恢复删除计算机	批量恢复已删除的计算机
联系人生命周期管理	在Active Directory中创建和管理联系人
批量配置/重新配置与CSV导入	创建用户、计算机、组和联系人，并通过从CSV文件中导入它们批量编辑它们的属性
基于模板的配置/重建	为用户、计算机、组和联系人的准备/重新准备创建具有公共属性的自定义模板
Exchange 邮箱管理
批量交换邮箱配置	通过导入CSV文件批量创建Exchange邮箱
大部分邮箱重建/解除配置	批量修改邮箱的属性
大部分邮箱迁移	单击即可将Exchange邮箱从需要的版本迁移到需要的版本
帮助台管理
基于角色/基于ou的安全委托	将不同的任务委托给特定用户，其范围仅限于特定的组织单位，并跟踪他们的活动
Active Directory 工作流
可定制的工作流	构建一个工作流结构，根据您的需要使用所需数量的工作流代理
Active Directory 自动化
完成重要AD任务的自动化	自动化关键的、经常重复的Active Directory任务
附加功能
文件服务器管理	在网络中添加文件服务器并管理它们的NTFS和共享权限
GPO 管理	创建GPO对象并将其链接到计算机和用户对象
AD 搜索	在活动目录中搜索用户、计算机、组和员工的联系信息

Features	Description	ManageEngine ADAudit Plus	Netwrix AD Change Reporter
Active Directory Auditing
WHO, WHEN, WHERE and WHAT of AD changes	Reports on who changed what, when and where in Active Directory
Logon/Logoff Audit Reports	Exact time of User Workstation Logon & Logoff time along with the Logon Duration
Compliance Ready Reports	Pre-defined reports for SOX, HIPAA, PCI-DSS, GLBA and FISMA compliance
Before and After values of a Change	Reports on Before / After attributes values of an object
GPO Audit Reports	Report on changes to Group Policy Objects		(Available as a separate component)
Real-time alerts	Real-time notifications on selected Active Directory changes via SMS/Email	(Supports alert via Email only)	(Supports alert via both Email and SMS)
Custom Reports and Alerts	Create your own custom reports or put up a request for one based on your requirements. Also schedule alerts via email for important events.		(Free only up to 3 reports)
History Reports	Get reports on Active Directory from a particular period of time in the past
File Server Auditing
File Integrity Monitoring	Monitor changes to the Windows system, configuration, program files, file attributes and folder
Access Permission changes	Reports on folder and file permission changes (DACL and SACL)
Failover Clusters	Audit and monitor the Windows File Server Failover cluster
Additional Auditing Capabilities
Custom Rule-based filter	Create report profiles based on custom rules with a filter
Alert Profile	Schedule alerts based on a certain threshold level or business hours
Archival	Sustain compliance by archiving and storing audit data
Auditing Scope
Supported Systems	Systems supported for auditing	Active Directory, Windows Server, File Server, NetApp Filer, Printer Auditing	Active Directory, Windows Server, File Server, NetApp Filer, EMC, SQL, SharePoint, VMware
Licensing & Pricing
License Criteria	Criteria used for Licensing	Number of Domain Controllers	Number of Users
License Type	Type of Licenses available for purchase	Annual Subscription & Perpetual	Perpetual only
Starting Price	Price for Active Directory Auditing	$1240 (perpetual license for 2 Domain Controllers)	$1425 for 150 users (at $9.50 per user).

Features	Description	ManageEngine ADSelfService Plus	Netwrix Password Manager
Key Features
Password Reset / Account Unlock	Users can reset their forgotten passwords and unlock their lockedout Windows accounts without calling helpdesk
Password Expiry Notification	Notify users to change password before it expires via email		(Available as a separate product)
Multi-Platform Password Synchronizer	Synchronize password and account changes with a wide range of cloud-based and on-premise applications	(Supports Google Apps, Office 365, Salesforce, HP UX, IBM AS400, Oracle DB, Oracle Ebusiness Suite)	(Supports Google Apps and Salesfoce only)
Employee Directory Update	Employees can update their profile information in Active Directory
Employee Search	Users can search for their colleagues information
Group Subscription	Users can opt-in and opt-out of Secruity and Distribution Groups at their will based on policies set by administrator
Change Password	Users can change their password from anywhere, anytime
Mobile Password Management	Self-Service Password Reset and Account Unlock via Mobile Devices
Client Software (GINA/Credential Provider) extension	Password Reset/Account Unlock from Windows logon screen (CTRL+ALT+DEL)
Built-in Reporting Mechanism	Reports on various aspects of user actions and their password status
Identity Verification Methods	Users identity are verified before they can reset their password or unlock their account	Security Q&A and SMS/Email based Pin code Verification	Security Q&A and Email Verification
Additional Features
Easy Installation and Deployment	Easy Installation and Deployment		(Requires .NET framework v3.5 SP1 installed and IIS 6.0 or above)
Multi-language support	Support for multiple languages	(Supports 15 languages)	(Supports 13 languages)
Automatic Password Reset / Account Unlock	Expired passwords/locked-out accounts are automatically reset/unlocked
Multiple Enrollment Options	Force Enrollment, Enrollment Reminders and Automatic Enrollment Options
Encryption standards	Encryption protocols used to securely store the Security Questions & Answers	SHA-2 and MD5	MD5 only
Licensing & Pricing
License Type	Type of Licenses available for purchase	Annual Subscription & Perpetual Model based on no. of users	Perpetual only based on no. of users
Starting Price	Price of the products for 500 users	$1490 (price of perpetual license)	Password Manager - $2750 plus Expiry Notifier - $550

Features	Description	ManageEngine Exchange Reporter Plus	Netwrix Exchange Change Reporter
OWA and Active-Sync Reports
OWA Access Report	Reports on OWA access to Exchange with info on the user, client IP, browser and server used in the process
ActiveSync Request and General Report	Reports on sync requests coming from all ActiveSync devices and on policies concerning ActiveSync
Exchange Traffic Reports
Mailbox Traffic Report	Mailbox traffic data based on both numbers and size
Organization Traffic Report	Track the overall number and size of messages sent and received in an Exchange organization
Exchange Mailbox Reports
Mailbox Size Report	Get the current mailbox size of Exchange users
Mailbox Size Growth Report	Report on mailbox size growth over a period of time
Mailbox Size Restrictions Report	Report on users with specific mailbox storage limits
Mailbox Content Report	Report to monitor emails based on keywords, attachment size, extension, etc.
Other Reports
Distribution Lists Report	Reports on Distribution Lists, its members and Inactive Distribution Lists
Exchange Auditing
Non-Owner Mailbox Logon Auditing	Report on all non–users who have gained excessive rights to access other users’ mailboxes
Mailbox Permission Changes Auditing	Reports on all critical changes made to mailbox permissions with details of who changed what
Mailbox Property Changes Auditing	Report on the changes made to the mailbox properties
Store Changes Auditing	Report on any store mount or dismount and store status
Address List and Recipient Policies Auditing	Report on changes to the exchange address lists and recipient policies
Store Group Auditing	Auditing of addition, deletion and modifications of Storage Group and Stores
Additional Features
Report Scheduler	Reports can be exported for later use in a targeted file format and scheduled for automatic email delivery
Custom Reports	Create your own custom reports based on your requirements
Licensing & Pricing
License Type	Type of Licenses available for purchase	Annual Subscription & Perpetual	Perpetual only
Starting Price	Price of the products	$1240 (perpetual license for 200 mailboxes)	$2200 (for 200 users). For both MS Exchange and AD Auditing.

免责声明:基于2013年8月1日的公开可用信息，本文并置了ManageEngine ADSolutions产品套件和NetWrix产品套件的特性。